Customers highly value the Surface Book 3's performance, battery life, and versatility as a 2-in-1 device, praising its lightweight design and ample RAM. However, some users experienced issues with screen quality, heat generation, and speaker volume. Concerns were also raised regarding the keyboard's reliability and the GPU's performance in demanding applications.
This summary was generated by AI based on customer reviews.
The vast majority of our reviews come from verified purchases. Reviews from customers may include My Best Buy members, employees, and Tech Insider Network members (as tagged). Select reviewers may receive discounted products, promotional considerations or entries into drawings for honest, helpful reviews.
Page 1 Showing 1-20 of 251 reviews
Pros mentioned:
Processor speed, Ram
Cons mentioned:
Screen quality
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
Well worth spending the extra $$$
|
|
Posted . Owned for 3 weeks when reviewed.
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
Full disclosure, I’m a Mac guy. Mac OS is far better than Windows. I had a virtual machine running windows because a few of my content authoring applications only run on the OS. I am an instructional designer/director at my college. I have a MacBook Pro, i7, 16 GB of Ram. It’s Ok.
I have a command center that is a gaming pc desktop. I wanted to be more mobile, so I bought the surface book 3. It’s an i7, 32GB RAM, 500GB hard Drive with a GTX 1650. I like to take notes so the fact that is a touch screen helps out. I am a lefty, so I have the claw when I write. It works extremely well. There is no bloat ware, as it’s a pure Microsoft product. The laptop is VERY fast. I am extremely happy with it. All zoom sessions run so well The only issue I had was the warranty. Best Buy wanted over 200 bucks for one year. I bought two years directly from Microsoft.
I like the surfacebook’s keyboard. It’s not the crappy flimsy keyboard. I can recline and work on it, as the keyboard is more like a traditional laptop. You will love this laptop. It’s a bit expensive, but well worth the $$. If you go low end, you’ll be lucky to get one or two years. Spend the extra money. You won’t be disappointed!
I would recommend this to a friend
Brand response from MicrosoftOutreachTeam
Posted .
Hi – Thank you for sharing your thoughts and feedback on your new Surface Book 3. It's great to hear that it’s a good fit for your needs. We hope it continues to serve you well. Best, Erica Surface Customer Care
Pros mentioned:
Battery life, Performance, Ram
Cons mentioned:
Screen quality
Rated 4 out of 5 stars
Powerful machine with few compromises
|
Posted .
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
tl;dr Overall, this is a great option for those looking for serious desktop power in a laptop sized case with touch screen. There are very few compromises made with this clearly premium 2 in 1 laptop. If you’re heavy into graphics and are tired of being chained to a desk, this should be near the top of your list. A couple of annoyances bring it down a star.
The Surface Book 3 is the machine I’ve finally been waiting for. I’m an avid hobbyist photographer who likes to touch up my work from time to time. I’ve been using Photoshop and Lightroom for a number of years to organize my pictures and tweak the ones I really like. Up until now, I’ve accepted that I had to use a desktop to manage some of the more compute intensive tasks such as panorama and blurring, two of my favorite techniques. I’d switch to a laptop with a pen for fine line edits, only my laptop didn’t always have the memory to edit files without them being flattened first. The Surface Book 3 is powerful enough to perform all my edits, with a large, sharp screen. This version also packs 32GB RAM which helps a lot when editing larger files. There’s virtually no lag at all when moving to different areas of a photo. I couldn’t even always say that on my desktop with 12 GB of RAM and a dedicated graphics card! Merging photos was significantly faster than the ultrabook I have, a 2019 HP x360 Spectre. One panorama made up of 25 photos took 2 minutes and 30 seconds to merge on the Surface Book vs. 5:12 for the same image on the HP (8GB RAM). Editing it after the merge on the HP was nearly impossible. While the Surface is a little larger than the HP machine for carrying around, it’s nice that I don’t have to switch back and forth to different machines, depending on the work I’m doing. This will also be great on vacation where I can edit my photos while I’m still in the moment.
One of the best features of the Surface is the detachable tablet mode. This makes editing using a pen incredibly comfortable. The tablet portion houses nearly all the compute power (minus the video card). While there’s no keyboard, it’s also half the weight of the overall unit. Detaching is as easy as touching a button. While certain edits were slightly slower, all the RAM is in the tablet. That goes a long way towards making editing practical. It then becomes your choice if you want the convenience of a tablet vs the power of a dedicated video card. The only caveat is you can’t detach if you have a file open from a connected source (i.e. USB drive). All the ports are in the keyboard. The keyboard also quadruples the battery capacity. The tablet can be docked as a laptop or in flipped mode where it will fold to the keyboard with the screen on the outside.
Since I have an active pen that came with my HP, I didn’t purchase the MS Surface pen. The HP pen worked very well for all I want to do, including easy photo editing. I could right click to get context sensitive menus. I didn’t have the eraser function that MS touts for its Surface pen. It’s a shame that at this price, MS, unlike its competitors, declined to include such a vital accessory. The keyboard is extremely comfortable to use with great key travel and good feedback. However, the Home, End, PgUp, and PgDn keys are awkwardly placed as alternates to function keys. (i.e. Fn-F9 = Home). Sound is clear and friends on a video conference had no trouble hearing me. The SSD drive is faster than any other OEM drive I’ve used, clocking transfers at 2.2GBs read speed in my tests. The docked machine should last well over 6 hours in power saving mode.
I was disappointed with the lack of Thunderbolt ports. It comes with 1 USB-C port and 2 USB-A ports rated for 3.0 speeds. MS sells its proprietary docking station with all the ports you need. It’s one of your few options if you want to hook up to more than one external monitor. The standard power plug has a proprietary connector which clips on with a magnet. That’s nice to avoid testing gravity with your machine. You can also charge from a friend’s USB-C if you forget your charger. A 65W charger I have for another laptop was nearly as fast as the plug MS includes. As great as this machine is, I feel I have to take off a star for the awkward keyboard, lack of pen and maintaining proprietary ports. Small changes could have made this much better.
I received this machine as part of Best Buy’s Tech Insider Network. Reviewers in this invitation-only program are provided products for the purpose of writing honest, unbiased reviews.
I would recommend this to a friend
Pros mentioned:
Battery life, Processor speed, Ram
Cons mentioned:
Screen quality
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
Just as good as my Ryzen 7 desktop
|
Posted .
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
“Reviewers in this invitation-only program are provided products for the purpose of writing honest, unbiased reviews.” The model I’m reviewing is the 13.5” Intel 10th edition i7-1065G7 @130GHz w/ 32GB memory, and the Nvidia GeForce GTX 1650 4GB w/ Max-Q Design.
Opening box: Opening the well-constructed box includes the Surface 3 laptop and the power cable. The charging cable includes a brick, but it’s very small when compared to other current laptops that I own or have looked at. It’s also magnetic, so it’s easy to connect, but also easy to pop off. I do like this option though because it’s not like the connection of old where it’s possible to snap the connector. I’ll gladly reconnect the cord rather than having to buy a replacement or fix the charging port down the road.
The brick is fairly light and measures 4 3/8” w x 2 1/8” h x 1 1/8” thick. That said, the laptop itself feels stout and heavy. Stated weight on Microsoft’s webpage is 2.79 lbs. If so, it’s a solid 2.79…not that I’m complaining. It feels well built, so I’m not afraid of using it as it should be used and not having to baby it. The casing is magnesium alloy or is it aluminum? I’ve read both and I’m not sure, but the color is platinum if that helps, lol.
Turning it on for the first time is exactly what I expected, except for the lack of bloatware (thank you Microsoft). After going through the initial setup and getting my Wi-Fi network connected, I expect to go to the Apps settings and start the tedious task of removing unwanted programs. But I only removed Office 365 setup because I already have an existing account. I may have removed an anti-virus program, but if I did, it was so quick that I don’t really remember. I immediately installed Bitdefender which I use on my desktop PC, Mac mini, and my Android phone. I had one install left, so I emailed myself a link and setup was uneventful. I also installed Bitdefender’s VPN which I also have an account for. After that, I installed Office 365 and the applications my account is signed up for. Obviously, Microsoft Word was needed to work on this review, and it works as it should. Once I signed into my Microsoft account, all my shared documents were available to me and I was able to work on this review from any of my PCs, which is so handy. Oh, did I mention it has facial recognition software for signing in? It worked well until I installed Bitdefender and clicked to fast to let it control the camera. Now I need to go find out how to disable that, so I don’t need to use my pin or password to log in. Edit: I found the camera/mic settings in Bitdefender and a simple click to allow Windows access and a restart got it working properly. Did I mention it has a camera on each side of the tablet? I’m guessing they are considered front facing since the tablet can be used either way, normal, or in the 2 in 1 mode.
So, what to install to test out this Surface Book 3. I’ll start with Photoshop. Installation was simple and it has no issues loading. I added a few filters to the application, but no brushes yet. I clicked on a CR2/raw file and the Surface Book 3 w/ Windows 10 loaded the application and photo into Camera Raw in 15 seconds. To compare, my Ryzen 7 2700 Eight-Core 3.2GHz with 16GB memory and a Radeon RX580 took 78 seconds to load the same raw photo into Camera Raw. I then chose a black and white filter and tried them on both machines. The desktop took 22 seconds to process the filter and the laptop took 27. That’s great considering it’s a laptop vs. a desktop. Also, the Surface is a quad-core and the desktop is eight (4 core plus 4 virtual vs 8 core plus 8 virtual) and it loads faster and almost performs as well! Then I just used the Surface Book 3 and tested what I feel is Photoshop's most demanding included filter, liquify. The Surface Book 3 can process the filter with little to no problem if the strokes aren’t very large. After about 3-4 swirls, the process hesitates as it tries to keep up. The lag is very short and acceptable. As I said, it’s a pretty demanding filter/process. All the user needs to do is watch the cursor. It will stay an arrow as it’s processing and then revert to the Photoshop circle to begin the next task. I wanted to try a game that uses a lot of resources. I chose Civilization VI because my desktop fan whirls when I play a long game. I installed the game on the Surface Book 3 via the Epic Games app and copied my latest save to the My Games folder in Documents. I opened the city which is on the largest map, I already won, and I’m finished with all tech upgrades. I just like playing to see how much of the map I can take once the game is over. The Surface Book 3 had no issues running the game. It appears to have the same wait time between turns, and I didn’t notice any hesitation or stutter in any of the movements such as the light spinning in the lighthouse. Except for the size of the playfield (not the 13.5 screens fault) the game is totally playable. I just prefer it on a larger monitor, yeah, I’m old!
Windows Update is amazingly fast installing system updates. Downloading was fast too via my Wi-Fi home network. It took 2 restarts to complete the needed updates including the windows 1909 update.
Speakers…well laptops aren’t the best when it comes to speakers and the Surface Book 3 lives up to that. The speakers do what they need to do and that’s about it. I listened to a few mp3’s and they sounded clear but lack any kind of bass. I wouldn’t say tinny, but like I forgot to turn on the subwoofer on my 5.1 home theater. Still, for doing daily tasks that require sound, the spoken voice should be above acceptable in my opinion. The Surface Book 3 does include Dolby Atmos for both the speakers and headphones, but it only offers on/off in the sound settings. No other options or app is installed. I did check full-range speaker option, but whether that did anything could be up for debate. I think it helped a bit, so it stays checked for now. Using a good set of headphones (I used a wired Rig set) through the port on the tablet and it sounded much better. Adding that bit of bass worked. I imagine it would be the same for gaming. I’ll add it in once I install and play a game on the laptop.
Reading Epub’s and PDFs: Reading Epub’s on the tablet works great. If you have the screen attached, you can use the arrow keys in Calibre to scroll pages back and forth. You get a two-page view like a dead tree version. I tried getting Windows to default to Edge for reading Epub’s, but it wasn’t a listed app and I couldn’t locate the right .exe file in the Windows system app folder, so Calibre it is. It works very well for a 3rd party app. Also, if the screen is attached or detached, you can swipe or touch to turn pages, just like an e-reader. Page turns are nice and fast with no lag. For whatever reason, Edge was still the default PDF reader (I guess I clicked make Calibre the default for Epub’s) and it works. It only shows single page view and I haven’t figured out if I can change that to a two-page view. It is very snappy with page turns and looks great like a PDF should. Edge does give me the option to stretch the PDF to full page width, thus making it easier to read and enjoy the pictures.
The detachable tablet has an awesome connection between the keyboard and the tablet. Very sturdy and the release key with the green notice on screen makes it very simple. This is the first detachable tablet/laptop I’ve had, and it works great. I wondered if Windows would work just as if it were docked/attached. Yup, I inserted a USB stick to see if it would show up in explorer and tada, no problem. Windows worked as it should. Edit: I read after typing this that Microsoft engineered everything except the batteries and GPU into the tablet, that’s why Windows 10 can operate with all its functions. It makes a great e-reader also. I have a paperwhite e-reader and several other e-ink readers and using this is nice and big.
What else? Well, the unit I was sent has 2 USB-A ports, an SD card reader, a USB-c port, and a headphone jack. It’s a bummer it doesn’t support thunderbolt USB-c, but from what I read, Microsoft feels Thunderbolt has security issues that haven’t been fully fixed or addressed. Battery life seems good. I’ve had this on and off all day doing this review, installing and running apps and it still has 51% life with 77% on battery 1 and 42% on battery 2. My battery setting is leaning towards best battery life, but not all the way to the left. Maybe about 60/40.
So overall impression. This 2 in 1 has several pros, including the reversible tablet when attached to the keyboard. Better yet, being able to use the tablet stand-alone with Windows 10 fully operational. The connection between the keyboard and the tablet is solid and doesn’t feel like I need to worry about it falling off. The green disconnect/attached popup is a welcome sight for new convertible tablet users like me. The charging cable is a 2 prong (nice) lightweight cord with a small brick making it nice and portable. The lack of bloatware was an unexpected and welcome surprise. The speakers being hidden behind the bezel and up on the tablet make for a better laptop listening experience, but with no subwoofer, the sound is less than ideal for any type of music. As for watching videos, presentations, or other spoken-word uses, they are up to the task. Nice that they didn’t put the speakers under the keyboard. I guess that wouldn’t work well with the tablet unless the keyboard was in the same area as the user. I do wish it could use Thunderbolt 3 so I could try out some of my adapters, such as additional ports or USB-c to projector, but I get that security issues must take precedence. If left to a short answer, I’d recommend the Surface Book 3 to my friends, especially the creative types, ones who need a touch screen or pen for work or school or those who f
I would recommend this to a friend
Pros mentioned:
Battery life, Processor speed, Ram
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
A Versatile Powerhouse!
|
Posted .
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
I have been in the Best Buy Tech Insider program for about a year now and have had the opportunity to field test and review multiple consumer products. Some good, some great and some like the Microsoft Surface Book 3… world class!
As a member of the Best Buy Tech Insider program, I did not purchase the Surface Book and it was provided by Best Buy in return for an honest unbiased review. The Best Buy Tech Insider program has never pressured me or suggested that I give anything but an honest and thorough test and review. Nor would I ever do that, as I too heavily rely on honest consumer reviews in my purchasing of items. User reviews are critical to me!
The first thing that struck me as I unboxed the unit was how well and sturdy the unit feels. I was curious to see, due to the 2-in-1 nature, that the connection between the screen and the keyboard body portion would feel flimsy and would easily break. It feels a 100% like a laptop when it’s in laptop mode. The connection has a strong magnetic locking mechanism and feels 100% solid and secure! That’s important to me. When I’m using it in the laptop mode, I want it to be a laptop. I don’t want to feel like I have to settle because it’s a 2-1 and a flimsy connection between the tablet and the keyboard is the price you have to pay for a 2-in1. Not so with the Surface 3!
I turned the unit on and was pleasantly surprised when Cortana’s voice chimed up and began walking me though her guided set up! I had flash backs to the movie “Her” as Cortana used her friendly and off the cuff and slightly humorous tone to guide me through the set up. One such line that made me actually smile was when Cortana said, “Next up… The legal stuff… You can decline it… but…you know… no Windows.” Really clever. It made other voice assistants seem so 2007. Now to be fair after the set up was complete, Cortana went back to sounding and acting like all the other assistants and her life like and natural tone went back to being as useful as all the other voice assistants we all have. It does show the potential these assistants have and that Microsoft is leading the way to utilize it to make a great set up experience that made this new laptop integration into my digital life seamless and easy. I utilize both windows and MAC OS and the setup was easy cross platforms for things like email and for linking my Microsoft account to my iphone ect. With the Surface 3 , I really love how everything is so intimately integrated with the Windows software and with the Microsoft built Surface hardware. Microsoft OEM software and Microsoft OEM hardware working in perfect harmony!!
After getting through the initial setup which was again, easy and fun. I could not wait to get started to see what this hot rod of a 2-in1- could do. The specs are off the chart! First up was to download Adobe Creative Cloud CC 2020. In my vocation, one of the hats I wear is to film, edit and produce training videos and milestone events for our organization. Most of the videos are 10 – 15 minutes but some can get as long as 30-45 minutes and require multiple camera angles, photographs, music and many many short intense action shots. Editing, previewing and rendering, adding filters and transition effects is very computationally demanding! These kinds of projects are the most intense tasks any computer can do. THIS SURFACE Book 3 2-IN-1 DELIEVERS THE GOODS!!! The i7 Intel 10th gen processor is just a powerhouse and when you have the 32mb of ram it’s off the hook. The SSD HD keeps the highspeed info pipeline flowing. I would highly recommend a 1 to 2TB external SSD HD to keep all your working files on and keep your internal HDD clean. With my external SSD, I had zero lag manipulating the videos ect. This unit also has an awesome Nvidia Geforce GTX 1650 Max-Q for the graphics. In addition to the video editing and photo editing, I also tore it up with some of my favorite games as well. So smooth and crisp and the Surface screen looks amazing!
So, I got so caught up in this as an incredible laptop that my excitement was reignited as I got ready to take it for a spin as a tablet! I pressed the tablet disconnection button located on the main keyboard and it light up and I felt the magnetic lock disengage.
Presto…I had an incredibly beautiful, lightweight, powerful tablet in my hands. Note: when disconnecting it will not save any work in programs you are running so save all your work prior to disconnecting and when you reconnect it, the programs will have been closed. The 2-in- 1 tablet mode is so awesome and versatile, It was so cool because after I put together a video and rendered it, I was able to pop off the tablet and take it into my wife and show her the video in tablet mode. So easy and functional! And the render times are just amazing!!! This Surface has some horsepower under the hood!!!! My boss was also impressed, I foresee more Surface books 3's in our office soon!
Another example of just how powerful this Surface is, is in Adobe Premiere CC 2020 the standard quality setting in the preview window is usually 1/8 to ¼ to have smooth playback especially if you have a lot of filters or effects or complex transitions from one seen to another. I cranked the preview quality to full and the Surface just hummed along at light speed….SO MUCH POWER!!! After video editing, I also do a lot of Adobe photoshop CC 2020 and Adobe illustrator in my line of work to fine tune logos, portraits and branding items along with creating hilarious meme’s.
The first thing I realized as I began exploring photoshop with this tablet was that a Surface Pen is a must have accessory! Now it’s awesome without one but it is phenomenal with one!!! After a quick trip to my local BestBuy to buy a Surface pen, I was ready to really see what this 2-in-1 could do with Photoshop CC. Note, you could buy an off brand pen but the Surface pen magnetically attaches to the tablet where others will not and the benefits of having a product that was specifically designed to work flawlessly and seamlessly with this particular Surface unit created by the same people that made the pen…well it’s worth the little extra for the Microsoft pen. I also have had a pencil for another pad that was not attached and guess what… whenever I needed my pencil it was at home in my desk or not charged ect. With the Surface pen… it’s always with the tablet 2-in-1 and ready to go. The Magnet is strong enough that I am able to place the laptop in my case and retrieve and the pen stays put!! I really like that. Although you don’t have to have the pen and the touch sensitivity with a finger when it’s in laptop or tablet mode is phenomenal, the pen really takes it to another level for working on the tablet! So easy to remove flaws in Photoshop ect! I also love that I can open word and just start handwriting! You can also hold the cap of the surface pen down and bam sticky notes!!! One click gets you the whiteboard program instantly and two clicks gets you snip and sketch which is super cool!
Literally world class laptop and tablet that stand alone in their respective modes but when you put them together, well the magic really happens!!!! I also love that such a powerful multimedia studio 2-in-1 is available to handle the most system intense programs and it’s Windows based!
Windows is so dominant in corporate America and it felt to me that you had to choose Microsoft for business and MAC for multimedia… I don’t have to anymore! This Surface will do it all! That’s a real eye opener for me and I love it. Frankly, I love this laptop. The fact I can do big league multi-media projects and still seamlessly integrate with my organizations Windows dominant world is huge! From tech support to utilizing Microsoft TEAMS. I have it all with this Surface 2-in-1.
So all this tremendous processing power and it tears through the toughest projects so what about the battery life? Well the specs say 15.5 hours. I worked 10 hours today and here I sit after work (so 11 hours) of hard use and the battery is at 51%. Granted I had a meeting and it was in sleep mode some throughout the day here and there. But I was working…all day. Emails, video project, word docs, excel, a little social media and Youtube ect. Just incredible in such a small form factor
You cannot go wrong with this Surface 3, so versatile and powerful, well-built and ultimately work enhancing unit. Then there is the fun side as well. If it can blow through high-end video editing, it is also great at high end gaming as well! 5 stars all the way. I will still keep my skills up on other platforms but no longer just consider Microsoft as a “word and excel” platform. Microsoft has truly crushed it with the Surface 3 platform and then the versatility of the 2-in-1! INCREDIBLE!!! I can’t recommend it enough. The Surface Book 3 is now my go to platform for all my work and play!!!
I would recommend this to a friend
Pros mentioned:
Battery life, Performance, Ram
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
High end laptop and tablet combo!
|
Posted .
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
I am a member of the Best Buy Tech Insider Network Program. Reviewers in this invitation-only program are provided products to write honest, unbiased reviews. I received a 13.5” Microsoft Surface Book 3 with the following configuration.
10th Generation Intel Core i7 Processor, 512GB SDD, 32GB Ram, NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1650 4GB GPU. This unit can be configured as a traditional laptop, or the screen portion can be removed to use it as a tablet or mounted in reverse on the base to use it for presentations. Per the specs, the battery life in tablet mode is about 6 to 8 hours and 10 to 12 hours in laptop mode. There are batteries in the base and the display, so the battery life is longer when the units are combined. The device uses a quick-connect magnetic charge port, and the included 102-watt power supply also has an auxiliary USB charging port. The power button, volume toggle, and standard headphone jack are in the tablet portion of the unit, and the base has 2 USB 3.0, USB-C, and an SD Card port. The tablet portion is held in place by an electromagnet, so it will not release if the unit is not connected to power and has a dead battery. The backlit keyboard is very responsive along with the touchpad, and the speaker volume and sound quality are above par for a portable unit. A USB-C docking attachment is available that so you can connect additional monitors and accessories and use it as a desktop unit.
The Surface Book 3 is a portable tool that is more than capable of serious photo editing. I was able to run full-powered editing software such as Lightroom and Photoshop CS. Photoshop recommends 8GB of RAM to properly execute the program and its effects, so the unit’s 32GB RAM far exceeded all expectations. Combine that with the improved processors I was certainly able to see a faster performance all around. The program is quick to launch and I was able to import over 10GB of my photos, post-process, and export RAW files in about half the time of my previous 16GB laptop. Being out and about I was impressed with the battery life under my heavy rendering load.
Overall, I was very impressed with the display. The colors were very vibrant while still feeling natural. There is a great depth to the tones. A real richness. Retouching is a breeze. The faster processor certainly shows in the rendering time. I did not hit any hiccups or lags regardless of how many layers my files had.
I would recommend this to a friend
Pros mentioned:
Battery life
Cons mentioned:
Screen quality, Speakers
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
Fast, useful and unique
|
Posted .
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
Pros:
* Plenty of power for all your app needs
* Beautiful screen
* Unique removable screen for Tablet mode
* Useful ports
* Adequate battery life when docked, OK when in tablet mode
Cons:
* A tad thicker and heavier than similar notebooks
* Can’t remove tablet portion (screen) with one hand once unlocked
* Slim stylus doesn’t firmly attach to the side of the screen
* Keyboard lighting is uneven when set for low backlight
* Pen our mouse still required - Windows still has some things not great for finger access when in Tablet mode
My Review:
If you’re reading this review, you’re probably considering buying the Surface Book 3 and are trying to figure out if it’s worth the money and will meet your needs. Hopefully my experiences with it will give you some insights and help you decide. I am a member of Best Buy’s invitation-only review program and have been provided this product for the purpose of writing an honest, unbiased review. I’ll try to cover the basics but also highlight the little stuff that you may not realize until after using it for a bit.
The Surface Book has been around for nearly 5 years and has always been a beautiful design statement with unique features to support conversion between use as a traditional laptop or full-featured tablet computer. In its native configuration, it’s a convenient pen and touch-enabled laptop computer; albeit a tad heavier than most competitors due to having dual batteries- one in the screen section for use as a tablet when separated from the keyboard base, and one in the base to increase battery life when used as a standard notebook computer. One of the novel features has been the arcing hinge that spans the width of the notebook. This looks really cool and works well, but forces the lid to not lay completely flat on the keyboard when closed and thus it’s a tad thicker than most notebooks when closed, too.
Not a ton has changed to the overall design since its introduction. It still stands out as a gorgeous and sleek notebook with compelling hardware and is a testament to what Microsoft can do when they design the hardware to work in synergy with the software.
I’m a User Experience Designer by trade. I spend my work days in the Adobe Creative Cloud suite of apps and my workplace uses Office365 and Slack as our primary office tools. Most of my time is deep in Adobe XD and Photoshop while chatting in Slack and keeping up with Excel spreadsheets, Word documents, etc… Creative professionals such as myself are interested in laptop computers like this to be the center of our workspace - something we can work all day on and still have the ability to take it with us to client, to another office or just to work away from our desks. All of the Surface’s prettiness isn’t worth much if it slows me down, and this notebook definitely gets the job done without complaints. I had no trouble editing a huge XD document while modifying assets in Photoshop… nothing so much as stuttered.
For fun (pun intended), I tried to hook up my Oculus Quest via cable and sadly the built-in graphics weren’t up to snuff. The Surface Book 3 is not really advertised as a “gaming” notebook, so you can’t really complain. It still had no trouble with any of the creativity apps I threw at it and multitasked like a true pro.
Not everything is perfect, though. While Windows 10 has a lot of great improvements to accommodate pen and touch input; its roots in a keyboard and mouse world are still evident. There’s a lot you can do with your fingers in Win 10, but fine cursor control is still necessary for many things and finger access on the touch screen just isn’t advisable or usable sometimes. When undocked in tablet mode, a mouse or touchpad are no longer available and it relies on touch or use of an optional pen like the Surface Slim Pen. Several times when using the screen in Tablet mode (detached from the keyboard), the touch drivers bailed on me and I couldn’t really do anything until docking back to the keyboard to resume control with the base’s keyboard and touchpad.
Another note about the Surface Slim Pen - it works really well and is comfortable to hold and even supports magnetically attaching to some Surface products. The Surface Book 3; however, only seems to allow this pen to attach to the left edge of the tablet and it isn’t really a solid mount. While not a dealbreaker, it would have been nice to support attaching the pen more strongly and to either side of the Tablet portion.
The built-in speakers are OK and were free of distortion even at the max volume, but the volume level isn’t really sufficient for listening in anything more than a quiet environment. At least you can easily plug in 3.5mm headphones or use Bluetooth headphones.
The power cable is a proprietary connection and attached magnetically to a special port on the keyboard base. There is also a connector on the bottom of the screen so it can be charged separately when detached. The plug, though, is a hybrid of a magnetic coupling with a portion that inserts into a slot, so take some attention to plug it in - you can’t just hold the end near the port and have them snap together. Also, there is an LED on the plug to indicate when it is providing power to the laptop. That LED, though, is on the side rather than on the end so you can’t see it when sitting at the keyboard or holding the tablet. Not a dealbreaker, but a small detail that could use improvement.
The keyboard has three levels of backlight intensity. At the highest brightness, it looks great and the light is even across the keyboard, but at the lowest intensity and when sitting at a typical viewing angle, the light looked splotchy and uneven as if the LEDs are too far below the keycaps so the characters are not evenly lit up. Not a huge deal, but if you’re working in a dimmer room and don’t want or need the highest brightness, you might need to hunt for that key you’re looking for because it just isn’t clearly backlit.
One last comment on the hardware - when you’re ready to undock the screen to use it as a tablet, there’s a mechanical release that can be kicked off by a button on the keyboard. Once unlocked and ready to be removed, you just pull the tablet off the hinge. The problem is that the screen portion is magnetically coupled to the hinge and is so strongly attached that you need to hold the keyboard down while pulling up on the screen to separate them. In other words, you can’t just unlock the lid and pull it off- it’s a two-handed operation. I appreciate that the lid shouldn’t just fall off when the latch is unlocked, but it would be nice if it didn’t require such a forceful separation and two hands.
It might seem that I didn’t like the Surface Book 3. On the contrary; I love this notebook. The hardware design is beautiful and it has more than enough power to be my primary computer for creative work in traditionally performance-demanding apps like the Adobe Creative suite. It’s really convenient to be able to undock the screen and work on a full-fledged Windows 10 tablet, too. Most of the small issues that I noted are nits; small things that can be improved but otherwise don’t prevent getting your work done quickly and easily on this awesome notebook. Some of these areas for improvement may not even matter to you, but it’s nice to be aware of them nonetheless.
I would recommend this to a friend
Pros mentioned:
Performance, Processor speed, Ram
Cons mentioned:
Screen quality
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
Surface Book 3
|
|
Posted . Owned for 1 month when reviewed.
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
This is my second Surface Book. I have an original Surface Book and after 5 years the screen started to show highlights at the edges so I decided to replace it with the Surface Book 3. The 3 is much updated, has twice the RAM, faster Intel Core i7, and cost less than the original. Transferring files and programs was simple, but I was glad I had a USB Blu-ray disc reader to install drivers for some of my older peripherals. The Surface Book 3 feels solid and is sleek and attractive. I use a Bluetooth Microsoft mouse, so as I tend to hit the machine's mouse pad when typing and it throws everything off. Turning off the mousepad when using a mouse was a simple toggle. This is my main machine, but at home I have the Surface Dock which allows me to have Ethernet connection for the Internet, more USB ports, and a large screen monitor that I can divide into three sections basically giving me 4 screens when/if I have 4 things open at once. The Surface Book 3 is as described and performs nicely. I certainly hope to get at least 5 years out of this one - although the original is still working with the slight screen issues as my backup.
I would recommend this to a friend
Brand response from MicrosoftOutreachTeam
Posted .
Hi – Thank you for sharing your experience with your Surface Book 3. We hope it continues to serve you well. Cheers, Erica Surface Customer Care
Pros mentioned:
Battery life, Ram, Weight
Cons mentioned:
Screen quality
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
A month in and still very happy with my purchase.
|
|
Posted . Owned for 1 month when reviewed.
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
I decided to splurge on a surface book 3 and love my new device. I write a ton of handwritten notes for my job so the tablet functionality was a must for my needs. I also run multiple programs at once requiring a device with decent processing power to run more smoothly. I wanted the ability to run engineering programs down the road as well, so the surface book 3 specifically stood out to me with 32 GB of memory and an i7 processor (albeit with slightly reduced capability due to a 15 watt power limit).
Windows 10, which is already set up on the surface book 3, is very intuitive and user friendly. I decided to pair my device with Microsoft 365, which was very easy to get up and running. The combination of the surface book with Windows 10 and Microsoft 365 made my last month of work much easier when compared to my previous experiences using other Windows 10 devices. Newly created documents are uploaded/synced nearly instantly from the surface book and enable me to quickly and easily access my documents from my iPhone or any other devices as needed.
My gripes so far are the price and the fact that the screen does have a little wiggle to it when attached to the base. The speakers could be a little louder but they do not bother me that much as I tend to use headphones. The sound quality is good otherwise. If attached to the base, the device lasts me pretty much to the end of the work day. If detached, the battery won’t last all day but I found that flipping the screen allowed a better note taking capability with battery power lasting all day.
The surface book 3 - 13.5” is the perfect size for a work/personal laptop in my opinion. It has some weight to it when attached to the base, which I like. The surface book 3 runs very smoothly and the transition from work to just browsing is seamless.
Overall, I’m very happy with the surface book 3 and keep finding new capabilities that I enjoy as I become more acquainted with my new device!
I would recommend this to a friend
Brand response from MicrosoftOutreachTeam
Posted .
Hello,
We're glad that you're very happy with your Surface Book 3! It's wonderful to hear that you love its versatile design, easy operation, and powerful performance. Thank you for your feedback; we hope you continue to enjoy using your Surface.
Cheers, Chuck Surface Customer Care
Cons mentioned:
Speakers
Rated 4 out of 5 stars
Awesome!
|
Posted .
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
I received the product from Best Buy and I am writing honest, unbiased review #sponsored #ad
Very easy to set up.
The speakers are just OK, not the best.
Build is solid, beautiful machine.
I absolutely love the face detection to unlock the computer!
Screen Resolution is amazing, we have edited tons of pictures in adobe and I just love the effect it gives.
Watching and editing videos is also wonderful because the resolution is just that good! )better than my MacBook)
Keyboard is not backlit, but I can live with that.
While working and editing I find the tablet very easy to detach which is a huge plus.
Processing is great, no delays or lagging.
I would recommend this to a friend
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
Photo editor's new found love
|
Posted .
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
Reviewers in this invitation-only program are provided products for the purpose of writing honest, unbiased reviews.
System Tested Specs: 1.3 GHz Intel Core i7-1065G7 Quad-Core | 32GB RAM | 512GB PCIe SSD | 13.5" 3000 x 2000 PixelSense Display | GeForce GTX 1650 Max-Q GPU (4GB GDDR5)
The latest Surface Book 3 may not have a lot of changes to the look itself, but the hardware is what has changed to better support end-users that need the extra power, memory, and support for engineering, graphical, photo and video editing, and finally powerful enough to support game play. With this said, I tested the one program we photographers go to; Adobe Photoshop Suite.
Load times were faster for both programs, and some of the images worked on using this unit were huge in size and detail. Cleaned, edited, and touched up various images and photos. Performed video editing. At times I had up to five images or photos open for editing and merging. It seemed even with all of these open and doing some video editing, there was no effect on the Surface Book at all as I was still able to perform my edits and manage changes to video and audio with no issues. I really enjoyed the tablet option as once I fully equipped myself with the Surface Pen (not included standard with the product, purchased separately) it was very easy to sit comfortably in any location and work without feeling tied to limited options. I did find myself grabbing the Surface Book over my usual practice as it meant I packed less and had less hardware to carry. The battery on this was amazing and could more than just a full day of photo editing to a day of normal work depending on how hard I was pushing the unit.
I would recommend this to a friend
Pros mentioned:
Processor speed, Ram
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
Best 2 in 1 ever
|
|
Posted . Owned for 1 week when reviewed.
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
Overall; it’s about the most beautiful and practical pc I can find in the market for my needs. I’m a bit disappointed at the performance when compared to my previous hp spectre 16gb ram i7 5th gen pc. For this being twice the ram (32gb) and several gend later in the processor, I was expecting my reports (large excel and power bi data models) to run at least on 1/2 the time, and they’re not..about 30% faster, but much faster in all else. I can’t stand the fact that windows defaults to energy saving vs. Max performance. It’s like buying a Ferrari to go 20mph. The first one I bought came defective, and I had to return/replace. Best Buy was great at supporting the exchange. The screen detach and re attach feature is awesome and makes it feel as a robust design. The monitor resolution feels odd, as compared to my Previous 3+yr old device that had 4K resolution. Some posts online mention a couple downloads of the Intel graphics that can help. I run 2 additional (3 screen total) setup, and it runs nicely, supporting the 2 external 4K monitors.
I would recommend this to a friend
Pros mentioned:
Battery life, Processor speed
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
I Love My Surface Book 3
|
|
Posted . Owned for 1.5 years when reviewed.
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
I love my Surface Book 3. It is a reliable, fast, and durable device. I use it all day and take it with me almost everywhere. No batter issues. I am a moderate to heavy user and the battery lasts me all day without having to recharge.
I would recommend this to a friend
Pros mentioned:
Processor speed, Ram
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
I Can Whole Heartedly Recommend the Surface Book 3
|
|
Posted . Owned for less than 1 week when reviewed.
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
I’ve owned a Surface Book 1 for nearly 5 years. It has served very well, and because it has lasted so long, it was an exceptional value, averaging less than $400 a year to operate, while giving me far fewer frustrations than a $1000.00 computer would. When the older one began to show signs of age, I knew I would replace it with the updated model. It’s simply that good.
The Surface Book 3 (SB3) looks identical to it’s first generation cousin. It has the same form factor, same odd hinge, same gorgeous screen, and mostly the same keyboard (the SB3 eliminates one of the keyboard brightness keys and the insert key, replacing them with screen brightness up and down – which I think is an improvement) . My newer Surface Book comes with a roomy 32 GB of ram, 512 GB of storage (256 can work, but it leaves little room to play with), and the 10th Gen i7 processer, and NVIDIA graphics GPU. This computer is very “lapable” (nod to Mary Jo Foley), which is where I use it 90% of the time.
Everything about the SB3 is snappier and faster. Apps launch more quickly, web pages render more quickly, menu clicks respond instantly, and because it has 4 times more Ram, Windows does not have to shuffle stuff around when multi-tasking – that means more open tabs at a time without system slowdowns. Even the screen detachment feature, which turns the SB3 into a tablet, is significantly faster separating in about a second, rather than the 3 to 5 of the older version. Boot times, sleep times – all faster. It’s possible to game on this computer, though I’m not a gamer. My daughter who also bought this machine says rendering of fast, 3D graphics is fast and stutter free.
The SB3 has received criticism for not getting a design refresh, but to that I say, “so what.” It is working well. If it ain’t broke don’t fix it. The design parameters seem to have found the sweet spot in the inevitable compromises of laptops. This mix has created the best all-around laptop in most computing situations. You might find a laptop better to some single use purpose (gaming for example) but you will not find one that does all computer tasks equally well across the board. And, can we please put to rest the tired criticisms of the hinge – it works great, is easy to carry when closed, and positions the screen precisely where you want it. It enables tent and studio modes as well.
But here is my number 1 reason to buy the latest SB3 – it has, hands down, the best keyboard and touchpad of any laptop on the market – windows, mac or Chrome. The touchpad is so good that I rarely use my (Bluetooth) mice anymore. The keyboard is perfectly laid out to allow fast touch typing. The Keys are at just the right height and give great tactile feedback. They can be back lit at two levels or left dark. I’ve noticed that I make fewer typos on the new SB3 and I think that’s simply because the old one was wearing out – still working just not as “springy.” I’ve tried the Dell XPS laptop and had to return it because the space bar was badly designed it would add or drop spaces. The Lenovo series had a terrible placement of home / end keys that would send your cursors all over the screen when you missed the return key. Even the Surface Laptop is just not quite as responsive as the SB3 – even the metallic one. So if you spend a lot of time on a laptop, and you write, or touch type, or program, get this device. The elimination of keyboard frustrations alone will compensate you for the extra cost.
I would recommend this to a friend
Brand response from MicrosoftOutreachTeam
Posted .
Hello,
Thank you for recommending Surface Book 3. We're delighted that you're enjoying its responsive keyboard, touchpad, and overall design. We hope it continues to serve you well.
Cheers, Chuck Surface Customer Care
Pros mentioned:
Performance, Ram
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
Great laptop with a lot of power and flexibility
|
|
Posted . Owned for 1 week when reviewed.
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
This has been a great laptop so far and is pretty powerful with 32 GB of RAM. It has been able to run multiple Adobe Creative Suite products at the same time with no performance issues. The flexibility of it being like an actual laptop (versus the Surface Pro series) is a great benefit to being able to work from any location, such as a couch, without needing a table or flat surface to work on. While I have had this laptop for a short period, it has served me well and keeps surprising me with how functional it is.
I would recommend this to a friend
Pros mentioned:
Battery life, Processor speed, Weight
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
Powerful & Lightweight 2-in-1
|
|
Posted .
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
Purchased this laptop for my daughter for college. It is very solid, fast, & lightweight and she loves the 2 in 1 feature. It also has exceptional graphics and battery life . She used a MacBook for the past 7 years and this reminds her of her Mac, only better.
I would recommend this to a friend
Pros mentioned:
Battery life, Weight
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
MicrosoftSurface Book 3 touch screen 2-in-1 laptop
|
|
Posted . Owned for 3 weeks when reviewed.
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
The product is great, it works very well and it is light-weight. It is compact and easy to carry around and the versatility of taking the screen portion without the keyboard is also a great feature and both sections can be charged and act as a battery for the laptop.
I would recommend this to a friend
Pros mentioned:
Weight
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
Better than the HP Spectre
|
|
Posted . Owned for 1 month when reviewed.
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
1.Our HP Spectres would break where you plug in the power cord. It plugged in like flashdrives, but over time broke. Not huge, but kind of annoying.
THIS surface book 3 has a unique power plugin; it's magnetic. You just hold the cord up near the plugin&it sucks it in! FABULOUS idea!
2. Altho I didn't mind, the HP Spectre did get very warm; vents on bottom of laptop.
THIS surface book 3 NEVER even gets warm! AND vents are on the top where the hinge is! GREAT idea!
3.Touchpad works better than HP Spectres.
4.keys work better than HP Spectres, where recently we'd have to really hit the keys harder on the HP Spectres.
5.THIS surface book 3 easily detaches, and I thought I wouldn't like that; but I do. Since I tend to carry around the laptop, it's really handy, and it attaches easiliy too.
6.THIS surface book 3 when detached, THE TOP using as a tablet ALSO has ability to plugin power cord! That's good, because yes the battery goes down faster when just using the top as a tablet. No biggie; plug it in.
7. It does seem that the battery does go down a bit faster than the HP Spectres, BUT not by much, and not an issue for us.
8.All in all, THIS surface book 3 is pricey, but so far, WELL WORTH IT.
It is STILL LIGHTWEIGHT, a bit heavier than the current HP Spectres, but the same as the first HP Spectre that came out--we still have that one and weighs the same...so is fine with weight. We only look at very lightweight laptops.That's our#1 priority.
Sad I had to spend so much to get a laptop that's lightweight, that ACTUALLY WORKS! (Had to return 2 HP Spectres within a few months, and gave up with them. They short-changed something in the way they make them now. Think it was the screen or hardware issue--awful--would act up immediately; go black,shut down,not come awake,flicker,cursor moved all over the screen,closed out of windows, shrunk windows, etc.,etc. on the HP SPECTRES. DISGUSTING as they are also expensive.)
9.I was told that Microsoft is high end premium; so far I'd say it definitely is. IF I have trouble with it, I will update this review. But have had it now for a month and am VERY happy with it. At least it WORKS, which is what I expect from a new laptop, especially with a price tag like it has. Microsoft has my vote forever unless it acts up like the HPs did.
I would recommend this to a friend
Pros mentioned:
Processor speed, Ram
Rated 3 out of 5 stars
I just can't love Windows anymore :'(
|
|
Posted . Owned for less than 1 week when reviewed.
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
I bought this for software design, UX/UI design, UX engineering so I needed a powerful processor and a lot of memory so I assumed that I'd be set with 32GB memory and core i7 but GOSH! This machine failed me! I thought it was a beast but it literally crashed and had a system error the same day that I start using it. Mind you, I had 5 professional software applications open at one time, well, including Chrome, but that was disheartening! The following day it froze and I had to FORCE SHUT DOWN!! Like seriously??!!! I don't know if this particular one is defective but I'm going to return it. I felt compelled to purchase the surface book because of the WACOM designed pen but it's honestly just WHATEVER. I can't really use it like I wanted. There are limitations to how many things I can do with it without using my keyboard. Also, when I would detach the keyboard for tablet mode, it was sooooo sloooooow!!! SO SLOW! So I couldn't even enjoy it for what I felt most attracted to in the first place. So yeah, moving forward, I purchased the 13" macbook pro with 16GB memory, core i7 and 1TB and THIS FEELS LIKE A BEAST! No crashes, powers up in SECONDS!, and flows super smooth! However, I am going to exchange it to the 32GB, core i7, 512GB storage. I care more about processor power than storage and since I want this BEAST of a machine to last me a few years, I think that's the wiser move to make!
In conclusion, if you're going to use this laptop with these specs for UX/UI design, software engineering, etc, I really DO NOT recommend it. It feels nicely built though so if it's for a high school student then yeah, and maybe okay for a college student but it's really not worth it for the price.
I'm going to buy the WACOM tablet separately to work on my designs easier.
No, I would not recommend this to a friend
Pros mentioned:
Battery life, Performance, Weight
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
Great Machine, Great Value
|
|
Posted . Owned for 3 weeks when reviewed.
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
I purchase the Surface for all of my sales staff. They check all the boxes. Light, powerful, battery lasts forever.
all around a great value.
I would recommend this to a friend
Brand response from MicrosoftOutreachTeam
Posted .
Hello Mike – Thanks for sharing! It's great to hear that Surface Book 3 fits your needs for work. We hope you and your staff continue to enjoy using them. Cheers, Erica Surface Customer Care
Pros mentioned:
Performance
Rated 5 out of 5 stars
Laptop
|
|
Posted . Owned for more than 2 years when reviewed.
This reviewer received promo considerations or sweepstakes entry for writing a review.
An outstanding item, had helped my daughter through University